CA
Tax Tutor
A

When workers put in hours beyond their normal shift, the factory doesn't just pay them for extra time — it pays a premium (typically double the normal rate under the Factories Act, 1948). That extra cost needs to go somewhere in your books, and where it goes depends entirely on why the overtime happened. That 'why' is the entire exam topic.

First, get the terminology right. If Ramesh earns ₹100/hour normally and gets ₹200/hour for overtime, his total overtime pay is ₹200/hour. But we split this into two parts: the normal rate portion (₹100) and the overtime premium (₹100 — the extra bit). The normal rate portion is always charged to the job or cost centre as direct wages. The treatment of the overtime premium is what changes based on the reason.

There are three situations you must know cold. Situation 1 — Specific customer request: If a customer (say, Arjun Electronics Pvt. Ltd.) urgently needs their order finished and asks you to work overtime, the entire overtime premium is charged directly to that job. The customer caused it, so the customer bears it. Situation 2 — General pressure of work / seasonal rush: No single job is responsible. The overtime premium is treated as factory overhead and spread across all jobs using the normal overhead absorption rate. Situation 3 — Abnormal reasons (machine breakdown, flood, power cut, strike): The overtime was unavoidable and not a real production cost. The premium is written off to the Costing Profit & Loss Account (i.e., treated as an abnormal loss, not loaded onto products). A useful memory hook: specific job → debit the job; general → overhead; abnormal → P&L.

One more nuance for exams: overtime worked by indirect workers (supervisors, maintenance staff) — the full overtime pay including premium is treated as overhead, not direct wages, regardless of the reason. Their wages are never direct in the first place.

📊 Worked example

Example 1 — Customer-requested overtime

Mr. Kapoor runs a furniture workshop. A client urgently requests completion of Job #42. Workers log 20 overtime hours at ₹160/hour (normal rate: ₹80/hour).

| Item | Calculation | Amount |

|---|---|---|

| Normal wages (20 hrs × ₹80) | Direct labour cost | ₹1,600 |

| Overtime premium (20 hrs × ₹80) | Extra amount | ₹1,600 |

| Total overtime pay | | ₹3,200 |

Treatment: Normal wages ₹1,600 → charged to Job #42 as direct wages. Overtime premium ₹1,600 → also charged directly to Job #42 (customer's specific request).

Total cost loaded on Job #42 for these hours = ₹3,200.

---

Example 2 — General production rush

During Diwali season, Priya Garments has excess orders. Workers do 50 overtime hours; normal rate ₹60/hour, overtime rate ₹120/hour. Factory overhead absorption rate is ₹40/hour (direct labour hour basis).

| Item | Calculation | Amount |

|---|---|---|

| Normal wages (50 hrs × ₹60) | Charged to respective jobs | ₹3,000 |

| Overtime premium (50 hrs × ₹60) | General pressure → Overhead | ₹3,000 |

The ₹3,000 overtime premium is added to factory overhead and spread across all jobs via the absorption rate — no single job is penalised.

Journal entry: Dr. Factory Overhead Control ₹3,000 / Cr. Wages Payable ₹3,000 (for the premium portion).

⚠️ Common exam mistakes

  • Students charge the entire overtime pay (normal + premium) to overhead when it's a general rush. Only the premium goes to overhead; the normal rate portion is always a direct wage charged to the job.
  • Students ignore the reason for overtime and pick one treatment for all cases. The reason (specific order / general rush / abnormal) is the deciding factor — always identify it first in your answer.
  • Students forget the abnormal reason category. If overtime is due to a machine breakdown or flood, the premium goes to Costing P&L — not overhead, not the job. Forgetting this costs marks.
  • For indirect workers, students try to split normal wages vs premium. Don't bother — indirect workers' overtime pay (full amount) is always overhead, no splitting needed.
  • Students write 'overtime cost = overhead' without explanation. In a 4-mark question, you must state the reason and then give the treatment. A bare conclusion with no reason earns zero or half marks.
📖 Reference: Overtime — Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Test yourself
Practice questions on this section, AI-graded with citations.
⚡ Practice now →