CA
Tax Tutor
A

Before a factory can calculate how much to pay Ramesh the machinist, it needs to answer two very different questions: Did he show up today? and What did he actually work on? These are the twin pillars of labour cost control — Time-keeping handles the first, Time-booking handles the second.

Time-keeping is the process of recording the total time a worker spends inside the factory premises — arrival time, departure time, and breaks. Think of it as the attendance register for wages. Common methods include the Attendance Register (a manual muster roll), the Token/Disc Method (workers pick up a numbered disc at entry and drop it in a box — any disc left uncollected means the worker is absent), the Time Recording Clock (the worker punches a card; machine stamps the exact time), and modern Biometric/RFID systems. Time-keeping feeds directly into Payroll — it tells you how many hours to pay for.

Time-booking goes one level deeper. It records how those factory hours were spent — on Job No. 101, Machine Setting, or Waiting for Materials. Methods include the Job Card (one card per job, worker records time spent on that job), the Time Sheet (one sheet per worker, listing all jobs done during the day/week), and the Labour Cost Card (a job-wise summary used by the cost department). Time-booking feeds into Job Costing — it tells you which job to charge the wages to.

The critical link between the two is Idle Time = Time Kept − Time Booked. If Ramesh was in the factory for 8 hours (time-kept) but only booked 6.5 hours to jobs (time-booked), the 1.5 hours is idle time. Normal idle time (unavoidable — e.g., waiting between jobs) is absorbed into the Factory Overhead rate. Abnormal idle time (avoidable — e.g., power failure due to negligence) is written off to the Costing Profit & Loss Account and is not included in product cost. This distinction is a favourite exam trap. Overtime premium — the extra 50% paid for hours beyond normal — is charged to overhead if overtime is general, but charged directly to the specific job if that job caused the overtime.

📊 Worked example

Example 1 — Idle Time & Cost Allocation

Rajesh works in Precision Parts Pvt. Ltd. In a week, his time-card shows he was present for 48 hours. His time-sheets show jobs booked: Job A — 18 hrs, Job B — 22 hrs, Job C — 4 hrs. His wage rate is ₹80 per hour.

| Particulars | Hours |

|---|---|

| Time Kept (Attendance) | 48 hrs |

| Time Booked (Job A + B + C) | 44 hrs |

| Idle Time | 4 hrs |

Of the 4 idle hours, 2 hours were due to routine tool change (normal); 2 hours were due to a sudden power cut caused by faulty internal wiring (abnormal).

Working:

  • Total wages = 48 × ₹80 = ₹3,840
  • Wages on productive time = 44 × ₹80 = ₹3,520 → charged to Jobs A, B, C
  • Normal idle time cost = 2 × ₹80 = ₹160 → charged to Factory Overhead
  • Abnormal idle time cost = 2 × ₹80 = ₹160 → charged to Costing P&L A/c

Final Answer: Product cost includes ₹3,520. Overhead absorbs ₹160. ₹160 is a loss written off.

---

Example 2 — Overtime Premium Treatment

Ms. Iyer works 50 hours in a week. Normal hours = 48. Her basic rate = ₹100/hr. Overtime rate = 1.5× = ₹150/hr. The overtime was done to complete Job No. 55 specifically at the customer's urgent request.

Working:

  • Normal wages (48 hrs × ₹100) = ₹4,800 → charged to respective jobs
  • Overtime hours = 50 − 48 = 2 hours
  • Basic pay for OT hours (2 × ₹100) = ₹200 → charged to Job 55
  • Overtime Premium (2 × ₹50 extra) = ₹100 → since Job 55 caused the OT → charged directly to Job 55

Final Answer: Job 55 bears ₹300 of OT wages. If OT were general (not job-specific), the ₹100 premium goes to Overhead — not Job 55.

⚠️ Common exam mistakes

  • Confusing Time-keeping with Time-booking: Students treat them as the same thing. Remember — time-keeping = total presence in factory (for payroll); time-booking = time on specific jobs (for job costing). Two separate records, two separate purposes.
  • Treating all idle time as overhead: Don't dump all idle time into Factory Overhead. Only normal idle time goes to overhead. Abnormal idle time is a loss — it goes to Costing P&L and must not inflate product cost.
  • Forgetting to compute idle time in numerical problems: When a question gives both attendance hours and job-booked hours, always calculate Idle Time = Time Kept − Time Booked. Examiners specifically test this step — skipping it loses easy marks.
  • Misapplying overtime premium: Don't automatically charge overtime premium to overhead. If a specific job caused the overtime (e.g., urgent customer order), charge the premium directly to that job. Only charge to overhead when overtime is general and not traceable to one job.
  • Using the wrong method name in theory questions: Token/Disc Method and Time Recording Clock are both time-keeping methods — students wrongly list Job Cards under time-keeping. Job Cards and Time Sheets belong to time-booking. In 4-mark theory questions, this distinction will cost you marks.
📖 Reference: Time-keeping — Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Test yourself
Practice questions on this section, AI-graded with citations.
⚡ Practice now →