## Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 — Audit Framework
The Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 (MSCS Act) governs co-operative societies operating across more than one state. Its audit provisions are stricter than many State Acts.
---
### Books of Accounts (MSCS)
Every Multi-State Co-operative Society must maintain books covering:
| Category | Detail |
|---|---|
| Money flows | All sums of money received and expended |
| Trade | All sales and purchases of goods |
| Balance sheet items | Assets and liabilities |
| Manufacturing entities | Books relating to utilisation of materials, labour, or other relevant items |
---
### Qualification of Auditors — Section 72
Eligible: Only a Chartered Accountant within the meaning of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949.
Disqualified persons:
1. A body corporate
2. An officer or employee of the MSCS
3. A person who is a member of, or employed by, an officer or employee of the MSCS
4. A person indebted to the MSCS or who has given guarantee/security for a third party's debt to the MSCS exceeding ₹1,000
> Vacation of office: If an auditor becomes subject to any disqualification after appointment, he is deemed to have vacated office automatically.
---
### Appointment of Auditors
| First Auditor | Subsequent Auditors | |
|---|---|---|
| Who appoints | Board of Directors (within 1 month) | MSCS at each AGM |
| If default | MSCS appoints in General Meeting | — |
| Tenure | Up to first AGM | Up to next AGM |
---
### Powers and Duties of Auditors — Section 73
Rights of Access:
- Right of access at all times to books, accounts and vouchers — whether at head office or elsewhere (branches included).
- Entitled to require information and explanation from officers and employees.
Mandatory Inquiries under Section 73(2):
1. Whether loans and advances made on security are properly secured and whether terms are not prejudicial to the MSCS or its members.
2. Whether book-entry-only transactions are not prejudicial to the MSCS.
3. Whether personal expenses have been charged to revenue account.
4. Where shares are stated to have been allotted for cash — whether cash was actually received, and if not, whether the balance sheet position is correct and not misleading.
---
### Content of Auditor's Report
The report must cover:
- Balance sheet: State of affairs as at the end of the financial year.
- P&L Account: Profit or loss for the financial year.
The report must also state:
1. Whether all information and explanations necessary were obtained.
2. Whether proper books of account have been kept and proper returns received from unvisited branches.
3. Whether branch auditor's reports have been received and how dealt with.
4. Whether the balance sheet and P&L are in agreement with the books and returns.
> If any item above is answered negatively or with qualification, the auditor's report must state the reasons.
---
### Special Audit by Central Government
The Central Government may direct a special audit if:
- Society's affairs are not managed in accordance with prudent commercial practices, OR
- Managed in a way that would cause injury to trade/industry/business, OR
- Financial position is such as would endanger insolvency.
Conditions and Procedure:
1. Central Government issues an order for special audit for specified period(s).
2. Appoints a Chartered Accountant or the existing society auditor.
3. Special audit can only be ordered if Central/State Government holds ≥ 51% of paid-up share capital.
4. Special auditor has same powers and duties as under Section 73, but reports to the Central Government (not to members).
5. If Central Government takes no action within 4 months of receiving the report, it shall send the report to the MSCS.
6. Expenses of special audit (including auditor's remuneration) are determined by the Central Government, paid by the MSCS, and recoverable as arrears of land revenue if unpaid.