# Independence of Auditor
## What Is Independence?
> Independence implies that the judgement of a person is not subordinate to the wishes or direction of another person who might have engaged him.
Independence is the bedrock of the audit function. Without it, an audit opinion has no credibility — the auditor would merely be confirming what management wants to hear.
---
## A. Independence of Mind vs. Independence in Appearance
Independence operates on two planes simultaneously:
| Independence of Mind | Independence in Appearance | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A state of mind that permits provision of an opinion | Avoidance of facts and circumstances that compromise perceived independence |
| How it works | Without being affected by influences | So that a third party would not reasonably conclude that integrity/objectivity/professional skepticism has been compromised |
| Who it protects | The auditor's internal decision-making | Public trust in the audit function |
| Key test | Would I compromise my opinion? | Would a reasonable third party think I have? |
> Both are required. Being independent in mind but not in appearance destroys public confidence. Appearing independent but not being so is outright fraud.
---
## B. Threats to Independence
### 1. Self-Interest Threats
Self-interest threats arise when the audit firm, its partner, or associate could benefit financially from a client.
Examples:
| # | Self-Interest Threat |
|---|---|
| (i) | Direct financial interest OR materially significant indirect financial interest in a client |
| (ii) | Loan or guarantee to or from the concerned client |
| (iii) | Undue dependence on a client's fees (concern about losing the engagement) |
| (iv) | Close business relationship with an audit client |
| (v) | Potential employment with the client |
| (vi) | Contingent fees for the audit engagement |
> Key exam point: Contingent fees for audit work are specifically prohibited — they create a direct financial incentive to reach a particular audit conclusion.
---
## Types of Threats (Overview — Beyond Self-Interest)
Self-interest is one of multiple threat categories. Others include:
- Self-review threats — auditor audits their own prior work
- Advocacy threats — auditor promotes client's position
- Familiarity threats — close relationship with client personnel
- Intimidation threats — threatened by client (actual or perceived)
(Detailed coverage of all threat types follows in subsequent questions.)
---
## Safeguards Against Threats
When a threat is identified, the auditor must evaluate whether safeguards can reduce the threat to an acceptable level. If no safeguards can do so, the auditor must decline or discontinue the engagement.