Worked Solution
✓ VerifiedAnswer: (D) ₹34 per hour
The machine hour rate is computed by dividing the total monthly machine overhead by the total machine hours (both with and without AI), since the special machine is used in all cases. The AI hire charges are a separate cost layer added only when AI is used, and are not included in the base machine hour rate.
Total monthly machine overhead:
- Depreciation: ₹66,00,000 × 10% ÷ 12 = ₹55,000
- Rent: ₹1,38,000 ÷ 6 = ₹23,000
- Other indirect expenses: ₹4,92,000 ÷ 12 = ₹41,000
- Total = ₹1,19,000
Total machine hours in the month:
- Without AI: 600 (B) + 900 (E) + 0 (V) = 1,500 hrs
- With AI: 450 (B) + 550 (E) + 1,000 (V) = 2,000 hrs
- Total = 3,500 hrs
Machine Hour Rate = ₹1,19,000 ÷ 3,500 = ₹34 per hour
This is the rate applicable when AI is not used (i.e., only machine overhead is charged, with no AI hire component).
Write it like this
1The skeleton
- Identify the three overhead components first — depreciation, rent, other indirect expenses — and convert each to a monthly figure; examiners award a step mark here even if your final answer is wrong.
- Use TOTAL machine hours (with AI + without AI) as the denominator — the special machine runs in both scenarios, so 3,500 hrs is your base, not just the 1,500 'without AI' hours.
- Keep AI hire charges completely out of this rate — the question asks for the machine hour rate when AI was NOT used, which means AI cost is a separate layer added on top; mixing it in kills your answer.
- State the formula explicitly — write 'Machine Hour Rate = Total Machine Overhead ÷ Total Machine Hours' before plugging numbers; one line, but it signals structure to the examiner.
2Examiner-rewarded phrases
3Common trap
Watch out — most students use only the 1,500 'without AI' hours as the denominator because the question says 'when AI was not used.' That's wrong; the special machine runs for all 3,500 hours, so you always divide by 3,500. Using 1,500 gives you ₹79.33 which isn't even an option, and you've already lost the MCQ.