Launch offer — 25% off with code LAUNCH-25 See plans →
Past papers/ Audit & Ethics/ November 2019
Paper 12 Qs
Suggested Answers · November 2019

CA Inter Audit & Ethics

This page contains all 12 questions from the CA Inter Auditing & Ethics Suggested Answers for the November 2019 attempt cycle, sourced from VSI Jaipur.

12 worked solutions ready
Sign up free to unlock every solution + bare-Act citations + how-to-write skeletons. 30 seconds, no card, no spam. Already signed up? Log in.
🎯 Practice this paper now

Drill 5 questions from this paper — instant grading

Real ICAI questions, instantly graded with bare-Act citations. ~5 minutes. No signup.

Drill 5 questions →
Q.b 05 marks medium Mutual Fund Accounting - Investment Portfolio, Gain/Loss on ⚡ Try this Q →
The investment portfolio of a mutual fund scheme includes 4,000 shares of P Ltd. and 3,200 shares of Q Ltd. acquired on 31-12-2017. The cost of P Ltd.'s share is ₹ 50 and Q Ltd.'s share is ₹ 40. The market value of these shares at the end of 2017-18 were ₹ 47 and ₹ 80 respectively. On 30th June, 2018 shares of both companies were disposed of realizing: P Ltd's share at ₹ 40 and Q Ltd.'s share at ₹ 82. Show important accounting entries in the books of the fund for the accounting year 2017-18 and 2018-19.
CTTP

Worked Solution

✓ Verified

Mutual Fund Investment Portfolio — Journal Entries

Key Facts:
- P Ltd.: 4,000 shares, Cost ₹50, Market at 31-03-2018 ₹47, Sold at ₹40
- Q Ltd.: 3,200 shares, Cost ₹40, Market at 31-03-2018 ₹80, Sold at ₹82

Under SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996 (Eighth Schedule), investments are marked to market at each balance sheet date. Unrealised depreciation is charged to the Revenue Account, while unrealised appreciation is credited to the Unrealised Appreciation Reserve (not Revenue). On sale, the Unrealised Appreciation Reserve is transferred to Revenue Account to reflect realised gain.

---

Books of the Mutual Fund — Accounting Year 2017-18

(i) On 31-12-2017 — Purchase of P Ltd. shares:
Investment A/c (P Ltd.) Dr. ₹2,00,000
To Bank A/c ₹2,00,000
(Being 4,000 shares of P Ltd. acquired @ ₹50)

(ii) On 31-12-2017 — Purchase of Q Ltd. shares:
Investment A/c (Q Ltd.) Dr. ₹1,28,000
To Bank A/c ₹1,28,000
(Being 3,200 shares of Q Ltd. acquired @ ₹40)

(iii) On 31-03-2018 — Provision for unrealised depreciation on P Ltd. [Market ₹47 < Cost ₹50]:
Revenue A/c (Unrealised Depreciation) Dr. ₹12,000
To Investment A/c (P Ltd.) ₹12,000
(Being 4,000 × ₹3 loss recognised; Investment now carried at ₹1,88,000)

(iv) On 31-03-2018 — Unrealised appreciation on Q Ltd. [Market ₹80 > Cost ₹40]:
Investment A/c (Q Ltd.) Dr. ₹1,28,000
To Unrealised Appreciation Reserve A/c ₹1,28,000
(Being 3,200 × ₹40 appreciation; Investment now carried at ₹2,56,000)

---

Books of the Mutual Fund — Accounting Year 2018-19

(v) On 30-06-2018 — Sale of P Ltd. shares @ ₹40 [Carrying value ₹47]:
Bank A/c Dr. ₹1,60,000
Loss on Sale of Investment A/c Dr. ₹28,000
To Investment A/c (P Ltd.) ₹1,88,000
(Being 4,000 shares sold; loss = 4,000 × ₹7 i.e., ₹47 − ₹40)

(vi) On 30-06-2018 — Sale of Q Ltd. shares @ ₹82 [Carrying value ₹80]:
Bank A/c Dr. ₹2,62,400
To Investment A/c (Q Ltd.) ₹2,56,000
To Gain on Sale of Investment A/c ₹6,400
(Being 3,200 shares sold; gain above carrying value = 3,200 × ₹2 i.e., ₹82 − ₹80)

(vii) On 30-06-2018 — Transfer of Unrealised Appreciation Reserve to Revenue on realisation:
Unrealised Appreciation Reserve A/c Dr. ₹1,28,000
To Revenue A/c ₹1,28,000
(Being appreciation previously held in reserve now realised on sale)

Verification: Total gain on Q Ltd. recognised in Revenue = ₹6,400 + ₹1,28,000 = ₹1,34,400 = 3,200 × (₹82 − ₹40) ✓ Total loss on P Ltd. = ₹12,000 (2017-18) + ₹28,000 (2018-19) = ₹40,000 = 4,000 × (₹50 − ₹40) ✓

PLAN

Write it like this

Time target 9 min

1The skeleton

- Start with the regulatory basis — write 'As per SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996 (Eighth Schedule)' in your very first line before any numbers, because the examiner needs to see you know the source of these rules, not just the math.
- Split your journal entries into two clearly headed years — write '2017-18' and '2018-19' as explicit headings, because the question literally asks for both years separately and losing that structure costs you easy presentation marks.
- On mark-to-market date, show the asymmetry rule — depreciation hits Revenue A/c, appreciation goes to Unrealised Appreciation Reserve (NOT Revenue), and write the narration explaining why; this one distinction is where most marks are hidden.
- When you record the sale in 2018-19, compute gain/loss vs carrying value (market), not vs original cost — show 'carrying value ₹47' and 'carrying value ₹80' explicitly in the narration so the examiner sees your logic, not just the final number.
- Close with the transfer entry for Unrealised Appreciation Reserve — many students skip entry (vii); add it and then write the one-line verification '3,200 × (₹82 − ₹40) = ₹1,34,400 confirmed across both years' to show the full profit is captured correctly.

2Examiner-rewarded phrases

“marked to market at the balance sheet date”“unrealised depreciation charged to Revenue Account; unrealised appreciation credited to Unrealised Appreciation Reserve”“on realisation, the Unrealised Appreciation Reserve is transferred to Revenue Account”

3Common trap

Don't fall for this

Heads up — the classic killer mistake is computing the sale gain/loss against original cost instead of carrying value (market price). If you write 'P Ltd. loss = ₹50 − ₹40 = ₹10' in 2018-19, you'll get the total right but the split between years wrong, and you'll also miss entry (vii) entirely — that's easily 2-3 marks gone even though your final number matches.

Q.c 05 marks hard Revenue Recognition - AS-9 ⚡ Try this Q →
Case: Consider the following cases: (1) Trade discount and volume rebate received. (2) Where goods are sold to distributor or others for resale. (3) Where seller concurrently agrees to repurchase the same goods at a later date. (4) Insurance agency commission for rendering services. (5) On 11-03-2019 cloths worth ₹ 50,000 were sold to X mart, but due to refurbishing of their showroom being underway, all client request cloths were delivered on 12-04-2019.
Indicate in each case whether revenue can be recognized and when it will be recognized as per AS-9.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Revenue Recognition - AS-9
✓ 48-line worked answer · ✓ 1 bare-Act citation · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.c 05 marks medium Banking - Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) Calculation ⚡ Try this Q →
The following information is furnished by ALFA Bank Ltd.: Margins held against letter of credit ₹ 200 Lakhs, Recurring accounts deposits ₹ 100 Lakhs, Current accounts deposits ₹ 375 Lakhs, Demand deposit ₹ 125 Lakhs, Unclaimed deposit ₹ 75 Lakhs, Gold deposit ₹ 235 Lakhs, Demand liabilities portion of saving bank deposit ₹ 1325 Lakhs, Time liabilities portion of saving bank deposit ₹ 722 Lakhs. Explain CRR and you are required to calculate the amount of Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) as per the direction of Reserve Bank of India.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Banking - Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) Calculation
✓ 19-line worked answer · ✓ 1 bare-Act citation · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.c 05 marks medium Consolidation - Minority Interest ⚡ Try this Q →
From the following data determine in each case: Minority Interest at the date of acquisition and at the date of consolidation. Case | Subsidiary Company | % of Share Owned | Cost | Date of Acquisition | Consolidation date Case-A | X | 90% | 2,00,000 | 01-01-2018 | 31-12-2018 | Share Capital: 1,50,000 (Acq), 1,50,000 (Cons); P&L: 75,000 (Acq), 85,000 (Cons) Case-B | Y | 75% | 1,75,000 | 1,40,000 | 60,000 (Acq), 1,40,000 (Cons); P&L: - (Acq), 20,000 (Cons) Case-C | Z | 70% | 98,000 | 40,000 | 20,000 (Acq), 40,000 (Cons); P&L: - (Acq), 20,000 (Cons) Case-D | M | 95% | 75,000 | 60,000 | 35,000 (Acq), 60,000 (Cons); P&L: - (Acq), 55,000 (Cons) Case-E | N | 100% | 1,00,000 | 40,000 | 40,000 (Acq), - (Cons); P&L: - (Acq), 65,000 (Cons)
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Consolidation - Minority Interest
✓ 28-line worked answer · ✓ 1 bare-Act citation · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.d 05 marks medium Earnings Per Share - AS-20 ⚡ Try this Q →
Case: Following information is supplied by K Ltd: Number of shares outstanding prior to right issue = 2,50,000 shares. Right issue = two new share for each 5 outstanding shares (i.e. 1,00,000 new shares). Right issue price = ₹ 98. Last date of exercising rights = 30-06-2018. Fair value of one equity share immediately prior to exercise of right on 30-06-2018 is ₹ 102. Net Profit to equity shareholders: 2017-2018 = ₹ 50,00,000 2018-2019 = ₹ 75,00,000
You are required to calculate the basic earnings per share as per AS-20 Earning per Share.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Earnings Per Share - AS-20
✓ 22-line worked answer · ✓ 1 bare-Act citation · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.d 05 marks medium Non-Banking Financial Companies - Income Recognition ⚡ Try this Q →
Explain the criterion of income recognition in the case of Non Banking Financial Companies.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Non-Banking Financial Companies - Income Recognition
✓ 44-line worked answer · ✓ 3 bare-Act citations · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.e 05 marks medium Lease Classification - Operating vs Finance Lease ⚡ Try this Q →
Classify the following into either operating lease or finance lease with reason: (1) Economic life of asset is 10 years, lease term is 9 years, but asset is not acquired at the end of lease term. (2) Lessee has option to purchase the asset at lower than fair value at the end of lease term. (3) Lease payments should be recognized as an expense in the statement of Profit & Loss of a lessee. (4) Present Value (PV) of Minimum Lease Payment (MLP) = "X". Fair value of the asset = "Y". And X = Y. (5) Economic life of the asset is 5 years, lease term is 2 years, but the asset is of special nature and has been procured only for use of the lessee.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Lease Classification - Operating vs Finance Lease
✓ 51-line worked answer · ✓ 1 bare-Act citation · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.2a 15 marks very hard Balance Sheet Analysis ⚡ Try this Q →
Case: Balance Sheet showing: Share Capital: Equity Share Capital of ₹ 30 each fully paid up - ₹ 50,00,000; 10,000, 10% Preference Share of ₹ 100 each fully paid up - ₹ 10,00,000, ₹ 60,00,000 Reserves & Surplus: Capital Reserve - ₹ 1,00,000; Security Premium - ₹ 12,00,000; Revenue Reserve - ₹ 5,00,000; Profit and Loss - ₹ 20,00,000; Dividend Equalization Fund - ₹ 5,50,000, ₹ 43,50,000 Non-Current Liabilities: 12% Debenture - ₹ 12,50,000 Current Liabilities and Provisions: - ₹ 5,50,000 Total: ₹ 1,31,50,000
X Ltd furnishes the following summarized Balance Sheet as at 31-03-2018.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Balance Sheet Analysis
✓ 41-line worked answer · ✓ 4 bare-Act citations · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.4a 10 marks hard Bank Financial Statement - P&L Account Preparation ⚡ Try this Q →
From the following information, you are required to prepare Profit and Loss Account of Simple Bank for the year ended as on 31st March, 2019. Data (₹ in '000): | 2017-18 | Item | 2018-19 | |---|---|---| | 71,35 | Interest and Discount | 1,02,25 | | 5,70 | Income from investment | 5,60 | | 7,75 | Interest on Balances with RBI | 8,85 | | 36,10 | Commission, Exchange and Brokerage | 35,60 | | 60 | Profit on sale of investments | 6,10 | | 30,60 | Interest on Deposits | 41,10 | | 6,35 | Interest to RBI | 7,35 | | 36,35 | Payment to and provision for employees | 42,75 | | 7,90 | Rent, taxes and lighting | 8,95 | | 7,35 | Printing and Stationery | 10,60 | | 5,60 | Advertising and publicity | 4,90 | | 4,90 | Depreciation | 4,90 |
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Bank Financial Statement - P&L Account Preparation
✓ 24-line worked answer · ✓ 2 bare-Act citations · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.5(a) 10 marks hard Consolidation adjustments - inventory valuation harmonizatio ⚡ Try this Q →
Consider the following summarized Balance Sheets of subsidiary MNT Ltd. for 2017-18 and 2018-19 (in ₹): Share Capital - Issued and subscribed 7500 Equity Shares of ₹ 100 each: 7,50,000 (2017-18), 7,50,000 (2018-19); Reserves and Surplus: 2,14,000 (2017-18), 5,05,000 (2018-19); Revenue Reserve; Securities Premium; Current Liabilities and Provisions - Trade Payables: 2,90,000 (2017-18), 2,46,000 (2018-19); Bank Overdraft: —, 1,70,000 (2018-19); Provision for Taxation: 2,62,000 (2017-18), 4,30,000 (2018-19); Total: 15,88,000 (2017-18), 23,08,000 (2018-19). Assets - Fixed Assets (Cost): 9,20,000 (2017-18), 9,20,000 (2018-19); Less: Accumulated Depreciation: (1,70,000) (2017-18), (2,82,500) (2018-19); Net: 7,50,000 (2017-18), 6,37,500 (2018-19); Investment at Cost: —, 5,30,000 (2018-19); Current Assets - Inventory: 4,12,300 (2017-18), 6,90,000 (2018-19); Trade Receivable: 2,95,000 (2017-18), 3,43,000 (2018-19); Prepaid expenses: 78,000 (2017-18), 6,000 (2018-19); Cash at Bank: 52,700 (2017-18), 42,500 (2018-19); Total: 15,88,000 (2017-18), 23,08,000 (2018-19). Other Information: (1) MNT Ltd. is a subsidiary of LTC Ltd. (2) LTC Ltd. values inventory on FIFO basis, while MNT Ltd. used LIFO basis. To bring MNT Ltd.'s inventories values in line with those of LTC Ltd., its value of inventory is required to be reduced by ₹ 5,000 at the end of 2017-2018 and increased by ₹ 12,000 at the end of 2018-2019. (Inventory of 2017-18 has been sold out during the year 2018-19). (3) MNT Ltd. deducts 2% from Trade Receivables as a general provision against doubtful debts. (4) Prepaid expenses in MNT Ltd. include Sales Promotion expenditure carried forward of ₹ 25,000 in 2017-18 and ₹ 12,500 in 2018-19 being part of initial Sales Promotion expenditure of ₹ 37,500 in 2017-18, which is being written off over three years. Similar nature of Sales Promotion expenditure of LTC Ltd. has been fully written off in 2017-18. Restate the balance sheet of MNT Ltd. as on 31st March, 2019 after considering the above information for the purpose of consolidation. Such restatement is necessary to make the accounting policies adopted by LTC Ltd. and MNT Ltd. uniform.
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Consolidation adjustments - inventory valuation harmonization, doubtful debt provisions, deferred revenue expenditure
✓ 53-line worked answer · ✓ 5 bare-Act citations · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.6 10 marks very hard ⚡ Try this Q →
Answer any four of the following:
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation
✓ 39-line worked answer · ✓ 3 bare-Act citations · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Q.15(b) 10 marks hard Goodwill calculation using super profits method with weighte ⚡ Try this Q →
On the basis of the following information, calculate the value of goodwill of Star Ltd. at 5 years' purchase of super profits, if any, earned by the company in the previous three completed accounting years. Summarised Balance Sheet of Star Ltd. as at 31st March, 2019: | Liabilities | ₹ in Lakhs | Assets | ₹ in Lakhs | |---|---|---|---| | Share Capital (Issued and subscribed 3 Crore Equity Shares of ₹ 10 each, fully paid up) | 3,000 | Goodwill | 510 | | Capital Reserve | 200 | Land & Building | 1,650 | | General Reserve | 5,293 | Plant & Machinery | 2,715 | | Profit & Loss Account | 517 | Furniture & Fixtures | 2,062 | | Trade Payables | 522 | Patent and Trade Marks | 30 | | Provision for Taxation (net) | 68 | Investments | 800 | | | | Inventory | 673 | | | | Trade Receivables | 546 | | | | Cash and Cash equivalents | 614 | | **Total** | **9,600** | **Total** | **9,600** | The profits before tax of three years are as follows: | Year ended 31st March | Profit before tax in lakhs of (₹) | Weights | |---|---|---| | 2015-16 | 1,910 | 1 | | 2016-17 | 2,050 | 3 | | 2017-18 | 2,950 | 5 |
Get the worked solution + bare-Act citation for Goodwill calculation using super profits method with weighted average profits
✓ 28-line worked answer · ✓ 3 examiner-rewarded phrases · ✓ Common-trap warning · ✓ How-to-write skeleton
✓ Join 778 CA Inter aspirants on catargettestprep Already signed up? Log in.
Start 15-min diagnostic