# Section 36(1)(xv) & 36(1)(xvi) - STT and CTT
## Sec 36(1)(xv) - Securities Transaction Tax (STT)
## Sec 36(1)(xvi) - Commodities Transaction Tax (CTT)
## Allowability
STT / CTT is allowed as a deduction only if the assessee has held the underlying shares / securities / commodities as stock-in-trade (i.e., the income from such transactions is taxable under PGBP, not Capital Gains).
## Reasoning
- If shares are held as investment → income is Capital Gains, and STT cannot be a PGBP deduction.
- If shares are stock-in-trade → income is PGBP, and STT is a business expense.