Launch offer — 25% off with code LAUNCH-25 See plans →
Microlesson · 5-min read

Time Rate vs Piece Rate Wage Payment Systems

# Time Rate and Piece Rate Wage Payment Systems

## Time Rate System

Definition: Worker paid based on time worked (hourly, daily, weekly, or monthly).

> Wages = Time Worked × Wage Rate per time unit

### Suitability

1. When worker's services are not restricted to one department (e.g., peon, supervisor)

2. When quality is more important than quantity

3. When output is machine-controlled (e.g., automatic chemical plants)

4. When workers are new trainees — output cannot meet minimum standard yet

### Merits

1. Simple to calculate

2. Guaranteed wages assured — workers feel secure

3. Quality is not compromised

4. Reduces Labour Turnover Rate

### Demerits

1. No monetary incentive to produce more

2. No distinction between efficient and inefficient workers

3. Labour cost per unit is high

4. Requires high degree of supervision

---

## Straight Piece Work Rate System

Definition: Worker paid a fixed rate per unit of output, regardless of time taken.

> Wages = Units Produced × Piece Rate per Unit

### Suitability

1. When quantity is more important than quality

2. When high supervision is not possible

3. When standard output per worker can be easily measured

### Merits

1. Simple to calculate

2. Strong motivation to increase production

3. Labour cost per unit known in advance

4. Higher production → lower overhead cost per unit

### Demerits

1. Risk of sub-standard quality

2. Workers may damage machines and waste materials to boost output

3. No guaranteed wages — workers feel insecure

4. Opposed by trade unions

5. Higher Labour Turnover Rate

---

## Comparison Table

BasisTime RatePiece Rate
Basis of paymentTime workedUnits produced
Efficient vs inefficientEqual wagesMore wages to efficient workers
QualityHighLower
Material/machine wastageLessMore
Supervision neededHighLow
Trade union preferencePreferredOpposed
Guaranteed wagesYesNo
Labour cost per unitHigherLower (with high output)

Worked example

### Example 1

Q: Worker A produces 120 units in 8 hours. Piece rate = ₹5 per unit. Time rate = ₹40 per hour. Calculate wages under both systems and state which is better for the employer if standard output is 100 units in 8 hours.

A:

  • Time Rate Wages = 8 × ₹40 = ₹320
  • Piece Rate Wages = 120 × ₹5 = ₹600

For the employer: Under time rate, Worker A's efficiency (120 units) is unrewarded — labour cost per unit = ₹320/120 = ₹2.67. Under piece rate, labour cost per unit = ₹600/120 = ₹5 per unit (fixed and known in advance). However, time rate gives more control over quality. If output is machine-dependent or quality is paramount, time rate is better; if quantity and worker-driven output matters, piece rate may be preferred.

### Example 2

Q: Why do trade unions prefer time rate over piece rate?

A: Under piece rate, wages are variable and depend on output — workers with lower productivity earn less, creating wage insecurity. There is also pressure to work faster, risking health and safety. Trade unions prefer the stability and equality of time rate where all workers in a grade earn the same, and guaranteed wages provide financial security.

⚠️ Common exam mistakes

  • Saying piece rate requires 'more supervision' — it actually requires LESS supervision because workers are self-motivated to produce more to earn more.
  • Confusing 'labour cost per unit is lower' under piece rate with total labour cost being lower — total wages may be higher (more output produced), but cost per unit is fixed and known.
  • Stating piece rate gives 'high quality output' — this is wrong; quality suffers under piece rate as workers rush to maximise units.
Reference:
Now that you've read this — what's next?
Move from understanding → mastery in 3 clicks. Each option below picks up from this lesson's topic.
Start 15-min diagnostic