CA
Tax Tutor
A

Think of Sales Variance Analysis as your post-mortem on the sales team's performance. You budgeted ₹38,000 in profit from sales — you actually made ₹36,500. Where did the ₹1,500 go? Sales variances break that gap into clean, exam-friendly pieces.

The single most important thing to check before writing any formula: is the question using absorption costing or marginal costing? Under absorption costing, every formula uses standard profit per unit. Under marginal costing, use standard contribution per unit. The formulas look identical — only the per-unit figure changes. Miss this and you can kiss your marks goodbye.

The Total Sales Margin Variance (TSMV) = Actual Profit from Sales − Budgeted Profit. It splits into exactly two parts:

1. Sales Margin Price Variance (SMPV) — Did we sell at the right price? Formula: Actual Qty Sold × (Actual Margin − Standard Margin). The 'margin' here is selling price minus standard cost, not minus actual cost. If you accidentally use actual cost, your SMPV absorbs cost variances that don't belong there.

2. Sales Margin Volume Variance (SMVV) — Did we sell enough? Formula: Standard Margin × (Actual Qty − Budgeted Qty). This is where multi-product questions come in, because SMVV splits further into:

  • Sales Mix Variance: Standard Margin × (Actual Qty in Actual Mix − Actual Qty in Revised Standard Mix). This tells you whether the team shifted toward higher-margin products.
  • Sales Quantity Variance: Standard Margin × (Revised Standard Qty − Budgeted Qty). This tells you whether total market volume changed.

The Revised Standard Qty is the actual total units sold, split in the original budgeted ratio. Always calculate this in a table before touching formulas — it is the pivot of every multi-product variance question.

The tree structure to remember: TSMV = SMPV + SMVV, and SMVV = Mix Variance + Quantity Variance. A 10-mark Paper 4 question will almost always ask you to compute all four and present them in a reconciliation statement. This topic appears in nearly every attempt.

📊 Worked example

Example: Two-Product Sales Margin Variance (Absorption Costing)

Given:

| Product | Budgeted Qty | Standard Margin/unit | Actual Qty | Actual Selling Price | Standard Cost/unit |

|---------|-------------|---------------------|------------|---------------------|-------------------|

| A | 400 units | ₹50 | 500 units | ₹145 | ₹100 |

| B | 600 units | ₹30 | 400 units | ₹125 | ₹100 |

Actual Margin: A = ₹145 − ₹100 = ₹45/unit; B = ₹125 − ₹100 = ₹25/unit

Total Actual Units = 500 + 400 = 900 units (vs Budget 1,000)

Step 1 — Revised Standard Qty (actual total in budgeted ratio 4:6):

  • Product A: 900 × 4/10 = 360 units
  • Product B: 900 × 6/10 = 540 units

Step 2 — Sales Margin Price Variance (SMPV)

  • A: 500 × (₹45 − ₹50) = ₹2,500 (A)
  • B: 400 × (₹25 − ₹30) = ₹2,000 (A)
  • Total SMPV = ₹4,500 (A)

Step 3 — Sales Mix Variance

  • A: ₹50 × (500 − 360) = ₹50 × 140 = ₹7,000 (F)
  • B: ₹30 × (400 − 540) = ₹30 × (−140) = ₹4,200 (A)
  • Total Mix = ₹2,800 (F)

Step 4 — Sales Quantity Variance

  • A: ₹50 × (360 − 400) = ₹2,000 (A)
  • B: ₹30 × (540 − 600) = ₹1,800 (A)
  • Total Qty = ₹3,800 (A)

Step 5 — Reconciliation

  • SMVV = Mix + Qty = ₹2,800 (F) − ₹3,800 (A) = ₹1,000 (A)
  • TSMV = SMPV + SMVV = ₹4,500 (A) + ₹1,000 (A) = ₹5,500 (A)

Verification: Actual Profit = (500 × ₹45) + (400 × ₹25) = ₹22,500 + ₹10,000 = ₹32,500. Budgeted Profit = (400 × ₹50) + (600 × ₹30) = ₹20,000 + ₹18,000 = ₹38,000. Difference = ₹32,500 − ₹38,000 = ₹5,500 (A) ✓

⚠️ Common exam mistakes

  • Using standard cost instead of standard margin in SMPV. The formula needs Actual Qty × (Actual Margin − Standard Margin), where margin = SP minus standard cost. Don't subtract actual cost — that drags manufacturing variances into the sales variance, which is wrong.
  • Forgetting absorption vs marginal costing. Many students use standard profit in a marginal costing question (or vice versa). Always read the question stem before writing a single number. The answer changes significantly.
  • Computing Revised Standard Qty using budgeted total instead of actual total. Revised Std Qty = Actual total units × Budgeted ratio. Using budgeted total units kills your mix and quantity variances both.
  • Marking Favourable/Adverse by gut feel. Always apply the rule: if actual > standard (for price) or actual > budget (for volume), it is Favourable. Don't guess — check the arithmetic sign and apply the rule mechanically.
  • Not reconciling at the end. Under exam pressure, students compute four variances and stop. Always verify: TSMV = SMPV + Mix + Quantity. If it doesn't tie, you have an arithmetic error somewhere. Examiners give marks for a correct reconciliation statement even if one sub-variance has a calculation error.
📖 Reference: Sales Variances — Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Test yourself
Practice questions on this section, AI-graded with citations.
⚡ Practice now →