CA
Tax Tutor
A

AS 17 – Segment Reporting tells companies: don't just show me your total profit — show me which parts of the business made money and which didn't. It helps investors, lenders, and exam boards understand how diversified enterprises (think a company selling both software and steel) actually perform.

Who must follow AS 17? Enterprises whose equity or debt securities are listed or in the process of listing on any stock exchange in India, AND enterprises with a turnover exceeding ₹50 crores (including excise duty). Smaller private unlisted companies below ₹50 crores are exempt — but ICAI loves asking this threshold.

Two types of segments: A business segment is a distinguishable part of an enterprise engaged in providing individual products/services (e.g., Rajesh & Co. has a textile division and a chemicals division — two business segments). A geographical segment is based on the economic environment — either where assets are located (production-based) or where customers are located (sales-based). The enterprise picks whichever reflects its dominant source of risks and rewards as the primary reporting format; the other becomes the secondary format. Primary gets fuller disclosures; secondary gets lighter disclosures.

The critical 10% Rule — this is asked every exam: A segment is reportable (i.e., must be separately disclosed) if it meets ANY ONE of three tests based on all segments combined (including unallocated):

  • Its revenue (external + inter-segment) ≥ 10% of total revenue of all segments
  • Its result (profit or loss) ≥ 10% of the greater of (total profit of all profitable segments) or (total loss of all loss-making segments) — take absolute values
  • Its assets ≥ 10% of total assets of all segments

The 75% Rule: After identifying reportable segments, check — do their external revenues add up to at least 75% of total enterprise revenue? If not, identify additional segments (even if they fail the 10% test) until the 75% threshold is met. This ensures material coverage.

Inter-segment transfers must be measured on the basis the enterprise actually uses (cost, market price, etc.) and the basis must be disclosed. Unallocated items (corporate HQ costs, general borrowings) are shown separately, not pushed into any segment.

📊 Worked example

Example 1 — Identifying Reportable Segments (10% Revenue Test)

Ms. Iyer's company has 4 business segments. Total revenue of all segments = ₹200 crores.

| Segment | Revenue (₹ cr) | 10% of ₹200 cr | Reportable? |

|---------|---------------|-----------------|-------------|

| Textiles | ₹80 cr | ₹20 cr | ✅ Yes |

| Chemicals | ₹60 cr | ₹20 cr | ✅ Yes |

| Electronics | ₹15 cr | ₹20 cr | ❌ No |

| Pharma | ₹45 cr | ₹20 cr | ✅ Yes |

Reportable on revenue test: Textiles, Chemicals, Pharma.

75% check: External revenue of reportable segments = ₹80 + ₹60 + ₹45 = ₹185 cr. Total enterprise external revenue = ₹190 cr (assume ₹10 cr is inter-segment). ₹185/₹190 = 97.4% > 75%. ✅ No additional segments needed.

---

Example 2 — 10% Result Test

Mr. Sharma's enterprise has 3 segments:

  • Segment A: Profit ₹40 lakhs
  • Segment B: Profit ₹8 lakhs
  • Segment C: Loss ₹50 lakhs

Total profit of all profitable segments = ₹40 + ₹8 = ₹48 lakhs

Total loss (absolute) of all loss segments = ₹50 lakhs

Greater of the two = ₹50 lakhs → 10% threshold = ₹5 lakhs

  • Segment A: ₹40L ≥ ₹5L → ✅ Reportable
  • Segment B: ₹8L ≥ ₹5L → ✅ Reportable
  • Segment C: ₹50L ≥ ₹5L → ✅ Reportable

Final Answer: All three segments are reportable.

⚠️ Common exam mistakes

  • Students apply the 10% result test to net profit only — Wrong. Use the greater of total profits of profit-making segments OR total losses (absolute) of loss-making segments. Mixing them gives a wrong threshold.
  • Forgetting the 75% rule entirely — After the 10% test, always do the 75% external revenue check. Skipping this step loses marks in practical questions.
  • Confusing primary and secondary disclosure requirements — Primary segments need full disclosures (revenue, result, assets, liabilities, capex, depreciation, non-cash expenses). Secondary segments only need revenue from external customers, segment assets, and capex. Don't give full disclosures for secondary — it wastes time and signals confusion.
  • Treating AS 17 as applicable to all companies — It only applies to listed companies or those with turnover > ₹50 crores. Don't apply it to a small private company in a problem unless explicitly told.
  • Using total enterprise revenue (including inter-segment) for the 75% test — The 75% threshold is compared against external revenue only, not inter-segment transfers. Read the problem carefully for what's external vs internal.
📖 Reference: AS 17 — Institute of Chartered Accountants of India
Test yourself
Practice questions on this section, AI-graded with citations.
⚡ Practice now →