Worked Solution
✓ VerifiedPart (a): AS 4 — Events After Balance Sheet Date (Year ended 31.03.2021; Board approval: 10.07.2021)
AS 4 (Revised) classifies post-balance-sheet events as either adjusting events (confirming conditions existing at the balance sheet date) or non-adjusting events (conditions arising after that date).
(1) Equity Dividend declared @ 7% on 15.05.2021 — This is a Non-Adjusting Event. The decision to declare dividend was taken after 31.03.2021. The obligation to pay dividend arises only upon declaration; no condition existed at the balance sheet date. Under AS 4, such dividends declared after year-end should be disclosed but not recognised as a liability in the financial statements for 2020-21.
(2) Fraud of ₹53,000 detected on 22.06.2021 — This is an Adjusting Event. The cash was misappropriated by the cashier on 05.03.2021, i.e., before the balance sheet date. The fraud was merely detected after the balance sheet date. Since the underlying condition (misappropriation) existed at 31.03.2021, the accounts must be adjusted to write off ₹53,000 as a loss or reduce cash balance accordingly.
(3) Building damaged by fire on 23.05.2021 — Loss ₹81,00,000 — This is a Non-Adjusting Event. The fire occurred on 23.05.2021, i.e., after the balance sheet date. No condition related to this damage existed on 31.03.2021. However, since the amount is material (₹81,00,000), disclosure must be made in the notes to financial statements to prevent the accounts from being misleading.
---
Part (b): AS 9 — Revenue Recognition for Rainbow Ltd. (Year ended 31.03.2021)
(i) Sale on Approval — ₹5,00,000 (dispatched 15th November; approval period 4 months): The 4-month approval period expires on 15th March (before year-end). 75% (₹3,75,000) was confirmed by 31st January. For the remaining 25% (₹1,25,000), no disapproval was received and the approval period expired on 15th March (before 31st March). As per AS 9, goods unsold under approval after the approval period lapses are treated as sold. Revenue recognised = ₹5,00,000 (entire amount).
(ii) Bill and Hold Sale — ₹2,40,000 (sold 31st March; delivery 10th April at buyer's request): This is a bill and hold arrangement. As per AS 9, revenue can be recognised even before delivery if: the buyer acknowledges ownership, delivery is probable, and goods are identified and ready. Since deferral of delivery was at Bright Ltd.'s specific request (showroom refurbishing), significant risks and rewards passed to the buyer on 31st March. Revenue recognised = ₹2,40,000.
(iii) Sale with Repurchase Agreement — ₹6,00,000 (goods supplied to Shyam Ltd.; repurchase on 14th April): Where goods are sold with a concurrent agreement to repurchase, the transaction is in substance a financing arrangement, not a genuine sale. As per AS 9, since the seller retains the risks and rewards of ownership, Revenue recognised = NIL. The goods should remain in inventory.
(iv) Interest and Royalties from Dew Ltd. — ₹7.5 lakhs interest + ₹12 lakhs royalties: As per AS 9, interest should be recognised on a time proportion basis and royalties on an accrual basis in accordance with the terms of the agreement. Both have accrued during the year 2020-21. Revenue recognised = ₹7,50,000 + ₹12,00,000 = ₹19,50,000.
(v) Consignment Sale — ₹4,00,000 (sent 25th December; 40% unsold at 31st March): Under AS 9, in a consignment arrangement, revenue is recognised only when the consignee sells the goods to a third party. At year-end, 40% remains unsold with the consignee. Only 60% has been sold. Revenue recognised = ₹4,00,000 × 60% = ₹2,40,000. The unsold 40% (₹1,60,000) remains as inventory.
---
Part (c): Intangible Assets — Surgical Ltd. (Development Expenditure under AS 26)
As per AS 26 (Intangible Assets), expenditure on an internally generated intangible arising from development can be recognised only if the asset meets specified recognition criteria. Expenditure incurred before recognition criteria are met must be expensed and cannot be reinstated as an intangible asset at a later date.
Total expenditure for year ended 31.03.2020 = ₹67 lakhs. Criteria for recognition met on 01.01.2020. Expenditure till 01.01.2020 = ₹15 lakhs.
Expenditure from 01.01.2020 to 31.03.2020 = ₹67 − ₹15 = ₹52 lakhs — this qualifies for capitalisation as an Intangible Asset (development phase post-criteria).
Expenditure up to 01.01.2020 = ₹15 lakhs — this represents the research/pre-criteria phase and must be charged to the Statement of Profit and Loss as incurred. It cannot be retrospectively capitalised.
Accounting treatment: Debit Intangible Asset A/c ₹52 lakhs; Debit P&L (Research/Development expense) ₹15 lakhs.
Write it like this
1The skeleton
- Label the classification in the very first line of each sub-part — write 'Adjusting Event', 'Non-Adjusting Event', or 'Revenue Recognised = ₹X' before any reasoning, because examiners tick that word first and everything else is support.
- For AS 4, pin two dates explicitly — date of occurrence vs date of detection/declaration — this single comparison IS your proof; without it your classification looks like a guess even if it's right.
- For AS 9, state the governing condition THEN apply it — one line like 'Under AS 9, revenue on consignment is recognised only when the consignee sells to a third party' before your calculation, or the marks for 'principle' are gone.
- For the repurchase (Shyam Ltd.) and bill-and-hold (Bright Ltd.) items, write the substance-over-form line explicitly — 'the transaction is in substance a financing arrangement' or 'delivery deferred at buyer's specific request' is exactly what the examiner is hunting for.
- Split the ₹67 lakhs in Part (c) with a date-anchored table or two clear lines — show ₹15L (pre-criteria, expensed) and ₹52L (post-criteria, capitalised) separately with dates, then state the irreversibility rule; this part has at least 3 scoring checkpoints and a single lump answer gets zero.
- End every sub-part with the accounting treatment or disclosure line — 'Disclose in notes to prevent accounts from being misleading' or 'Debit Intangible Asset ₹52L; Debit P&L ₹15L' — these closing lines are often separately marked and students skip them.
2Examiner-rewarded phrases
3Common trap
The deadliest move on this paper: treating the repurchase agreement (Shyam Ltd.) as a normal sale and booking ₹6,00,000 revenue — that's a full sub-part wiped out. If there's a concurrent agreement to repurchase, your brain should immediately fire 'financing arrangement, NIL revenue' before you even read the numbers. Also watch the AS 26 trap — students capitalise the entire ₹67 lakhs because 'it's development expenditure', completely missing that pre-criteria spend (₹15L) is permanently expensed and the split date is the whole answer.