Worked Solution
✓ VerifiedInvestment Account – Equity Shares in Nexus Ltd.
(For the year ended 31st March, 2025 — as per AS 13: Accounting for Investments)
| Dr. | Cr. | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Date | Particulars | Shares | ₹ | Date | Particulars | Shares | ₹ |
| 01.04.24 | To Balance b/d | 20,000 | 2,40,000 | 01.11.24 | By Bank A/c (Sale @ ₹26) | 11,500 | 2,99,000 |
| Apr-24 | To Bank A/c — Bonus Shares (NIL cost) | 4,000 | — | 31.03.25 | By Balance c/d | 21,500 | 2,38,455 |
| 31.07.24 | To Bank A/c — Rights subscribed (9,000 × ₹14) | 9,000 | 1,26,000 | ||||
| 01.11.24 | To Profit & Loss A/c (Profit on sale) | — | 1,71,455 | ||||
| Total | 33,000 | 5,37,455 | Total | 33,000 | 5,37,455 |
Items credited directly to Profit & Loss A/c (not routed through Investment A/c):
(i) Profit on renouncement of rights (9,000 rights × ₹1) = ₹9,000 — Under AS 13, consideration received on renouncing rights is treated as income and credited to P&L.
(ii) Dividend income (20,000 × ₹10 × 15%) = ₹30,000 — This dividend relates to FY 2023-24 during which Ms. Nisha was already a shareholder; it is a post-acquisition dividend and hence recognised as income in P&L per AS 13, not deducted from cost of investment.
Key Accounting Principles Applied (AS 13):
Bonus Shares: Under AS 13, bonus shares received carry no additional cost. The cost of the original holding is spread over the enlarged number of shares, reducing the average cost per share. Accordingly, 4,000 bonus shares are recorded at NIL cost.
Rights Shares Subscribed: Cost of rights shares subscribed is the purchase price paid — 9,000 shares × ₹14 = ₹1,26,000.
Average Cost Method: After rights subscription, total cost of ₹3,66,000 is averaged over 33,000 shares (= ₹11.09 per share, i.e., 122/11). On sale of 11,500 shares, cost is computed at this average.
Closing Balance: 21,500 shares at average cost = ₹2,38,455.
Write it like this
1The skeleton
- Set up the T-account with four columns on each side (Date | Particulars | Shares | ₹) — examiners check format first; missing the 'Shares' column loses a mark before they even read your numbers.
- Record bonus shares at NIL cost on the Dr. side and immediately recalculate average cost per share in your working — the whole question hinges on this average, so show it explicitly as a separate working note.
- Split rights entitlement into two lines: subscribed (9,000 × ₹14 → Dr. side) and renounced (9,000 × ₹1 → P&L note below the account) — never merge them, examiner ticks each one separately.
- Keep dividend and renouncement proceeds OUT of the investment account — note them below as 'credited directly to P&L' with the AS 13 reasoning written in one line each; this is where the theory marks hide.
- Show profit on sale as a balancing figure on the Dr. side (not Cr.) and derive sale proceeds on the Cr. side at ₹26 per share — getting the sides right is a 1-mark trap most students hit.
- Write closing balance shares (21,500) × average cost to cross-verify ₹2,38,455 — state the average cost fraction clearly (₹3,66,000 ÷ 33,000) so the examiner can follow your logic even if a small arithmetic error crept in.
2Examiner-rewarded phrases
3Common trap
The single biggest killer: students subtract the rights renouncement proceeds (₹9,000) from the cost of the investment account instead of routing it to P&L — that's the pre-AS 13 treatment, and it will corrupt your average cost AND your closing balance simultaneously, costing you 3-4 marks in one shot.