Launch offer — 25% off with code LAUNCH-25 See plans →
Microlesson · 5-min read

SA-450: Evaluation of Misstatements Identified During the Audit

## SA-450: Evaluation of Misstatements Identified During the Audit

### Step 1: Accumulate Misstatements

  • Accumulate all misstatements found during the audit
  • Exception: Trivial misstatements (below a pre-determined de minimis threshold) need not be accumulated
  • The evaluation is based on the aggregate effect, not just individual items

---

### Step 2: Determine Materiality (Per SA-320)

Evaluate each misstatement based on:

  • Amount of the misstatement
  • Nature of the uncorrected misstatement
  • Circumstances of occurrence

Revise the audit plan and strategy accordingly if needed.

---

### Step 3: Request Management to Examine

  • Auditor requests management to examine the affected Account Balance, Class of transactions, or Disclosure (ACD)
  • Purpose: understand the root cause of the misstatement
  • If management examines the issue but the misstatement still exists → perform additional audit procedures

---

### Step 4: Communicate Misstatements

#### To Management:

Management CorrectsManagement Refuses (All or Some)
Ensure correction and evaluate itObtain reasons for refusal
Enables accurate books & recordsConsider whether FS are free from material misstatement
Reduces RMM in future FSIf not free → issue Modified Opinion
Communication must be timely so management can evaluate and take action

#### To TCWG (Required when Modified Opinion is Being Considered):

1. Uncorrected misstatements

2. Effect on the auditor's opinion

3. Request TCWG to correct misstatements related to prior periods (transactions, balances, disclosures, FS as a whole)

> Note: Communication to TCWG is required unless prohibited by law.

---

### Step 5: Obtain Written Representation (WR)

  • From management AND TCWG
  • Content: Effect of uncorrected misstatements is immaterial to the FS
  • A summary of uncorrected misstatements must be attached to or included in the WR

---

### Documentation

The auditor must document:

1. The amount below which misstatements are considered trivial

2. All misstatements accumulated — whether corrected or not

3. Auditor's conclusion on the materiality of uncorrected misstatements

Worked example

### Example 1

During the audit of a trading company, the auditor identifies three misstatements: (1) ₹40,000 overstatement in trade payables, (2) ₹25,000 understatement in accruals, and (3) ₹8,000 incorrect depreciation charge. Management corrects items (1) and (2) but refuses to correct (3), claiming it is immaterial. The auditor must document the ₹8,000 uncorrected misstatement, obtain management's written representation that its effect is immaterial, and attach a schedule of uncorrected misstatements to the WR.

### Example 2

An auditor identifies revenue overstated by ₹5 lakhs due to premature revenue recognition — above performance materiality of ₹3 lakhs. Management refuses to correct this. The auditor communicates to TCWG: (a) the ₹5 lakh uncorrected misstatement, (b) the proposed modification to the audit opinion (qualified opinion for material misstatement), and (c) a request to TCWG to direct management to correct the error. If TCWG also refuses, a qualified opinion is issued.

### Example 3

An auditor finds five individually small misstatements during the audit, each below performance materiality. In aggregate, they total ₹4.2 lakhs — above overall materiality of ₹4 lakhs. Since the aggregate effect is material, the auditor cannot ignore these items. All five misstatements must be communicated to management, and the auditor must request corrections. This illustrates why SA-450 requires accumulation of all misstatements throughout the audit.

⚠️ Common exam mistakes

  • Not accumulating misstatements throughout the audit — individual items below materiality can become material in aggregate and must be tracked
  • Confusing trivial misstatements (can be completely ignored) with immaterial uncorrected misstatements (must be documented and covered in the WR)
  • Forgetting to communicate to TCWG — this is required when the auditor is considering a modified opinion, not just when management has been informed
  • Assuming WR is only required from management — SA-450 requires WR from BOTH management AND TCWG regarding the effect of uncorrected misstatements
  • Skipping the step of requesting management to examine the account/class/disclosure to understand the cause before jumping to modified opinion
Reference: — SA 450
Now that you've read this — what's next?
Move from understanding → mastery in 3 clicks. Each option below picks up from this lesson's topic.
Start 15-min diagnostic